Why Tone Matters in a World of Mockery

This special blog is only available to subscribers. Please keep and eye out for my upcoming book, Mere Christianity for the Digital Age: Can Faith Survive the Internet? (available this fall from Trilogy Publishing) and keep it in prayer.

“Let your speech always be gracious, seasoned with salt, so that you may know how you ought to answer each person.”

— Colossians 4:6

In today’s digital world, tone often carries more weight than content. A well-reasoned response can be dismissed with an eye-roll emoji. A thoughtful comment can be buried beneath a mountain of sarcasm. On platforms where speed and snark dominate, how we say something often determines whether we’re heard at all.

This is especially true for Christians engaging with skeptics online. When sarcasm becomes our default mode, we lose something vital: credibility, clarity, and Christlikeness.

Mockery Is the Air We Breathe

The internet rewards mockery. It’s viral. It’s entertaining. And it gives the illusion of superiority without the burden of substance. Think of memes like “Religion: Because thinking is hard,” or “Prayer: The original do-nothing policy.” These aren’t arguments—they’re applause lines designed to bypass the mind and appeal directly to cynicism.

Christians can fall into the same trap. We respond with our own zingers, our own memes, our own “gotchas.” But when we fight sarcasm with sarcasm, we’re not countering the culture—we’re mirroring it.

The Wit of Chesterton vs. the Snark of the Internet

G.K. Chesterton was no stranger to humor. He used wit like a surgeon’s scalpel: with precision and purpose. His humor was never cruel. It was grounded in joy, in confidence, and in the deep sense that truth does not fear laughter.

Contrast that with today’s internet discourse. Online mockery is often a defense mechanism—a shield against sincerity. It says, “If I laugh at you, I don’t have to listen to you.” That posture is tragic—and contagious.

Christians are not called to out-snark the world. We’re called to stand apart. That means choosing substance over spectacle, clarity over cleverness, and grace over grimace.

Jesus Didn’t Mock His Enemies

It’s striking how Jesus responded to mockery. He was called a drunkard, a blasphemer, demon-possessed. He was mocked with a crown of thorns and a robe of ridicule. And how did He answer?

Not with a cutting comeback.

Not with a meme.

Often, He didn’t answer at all.

When He did speak, His words were disarming in their clarity and unsettling in their grace. He asked questions. He told stories. He drew lines in the sand—but never crossed them into cruelty.

The Real Power of Gentle Speech

Colossians 4:6 calls us to let our speech be “gracious, seasoned with salt.” That doesn’t mean bland. It means flavorful. Persuasive. Healing. Salt was used to preserve and to purify. That’s the power of gentle speech in a decaying culture.

When we speak graciously, we don’t surrender truth—we give it a form that others can actually hear. We might not win applause. But we might win a hearing.

Tone as Evangelism

Tone isn’t just a matter of manners. It’s a matter of mission.

When a Christian engages with humility in a thread filled with hostility, it stands out. When we refuse to return insult for insult, we become a kind of living parable. We embody the gospel we proclaim.

That doesn’t mean we avoid hard truths. But we carry them like lanterns, not like sledgehammers.

Examples Worth Following

• Atticus Finch, in To Kill a Mockingbird, responds to scorn with composure. His calmness is not weakness—it’s moral authority.
• Thomas More, in A Man for All Seasons, faces betrayal and condemnation with reasoned conviction and quiet strength.
• Jesus, in His trial, remains silent before Pilate—not because He had no answer, but because He refused to play their game.

Each offers a model of strength through restraint.

How to Speak with Salt

1. Pause before you post: Is your tone defensive or redemptive?
2. Use questions, not accusations: “What do you mean by that?” often goes further than “That’s ridiculous.”
3. Watch your humor: Is it at someone’s expense—or does it invite reflection?
4. Don’t feed the trolls: Sometimes, silence is the most powerful answer.
5. Pray as you write: Ask God to make your words both true and beautiful.

Final Thought

We live in a world where mockery travels faster than meaning. But that doesn’t mean we have to play along.

Sarcasm isn’t a strategy. It’s a substitute for one. Our strategy is older and deeper: speak the truth in love. Season every word with grace. And trust that, over time, people will remember not just what we said—but how we said it.

It might not go viral. But it might change a heart.