Why Love Demands More Than Agreement
This special blog is only available to subscribers. Please keep and eye out for my upcoming book, Mere Christianity for the Digital Age: Can Faith Survive the Internet? (available this fall from Trilogy Publishing) and keep it in prayer.
“Faithful are the wounds of a friend; profuse are the kisses of an enemy.”
– Proverbs 27:6
In today’s cultural climate, love has been redefined. It no longer means pursuing another’s good, even when it’s hard—it means agreeing with their feelings, affirming their identity, and approving their choices without question. Disagreement is viewed as harm. Correction is seen as cruelty. And the one who dares to say, “That’s not true” is quickly labeled unloving.
But is affirmation always loving? And is disagreement always hate?
This blog pushes back on the modern lie that love equals affirmation and shows why the gospel offers something far deeper, far better, and far more transformative.
The Rise of Affirmation Culture
Affirmation culture didn’t come out of nowhere. It emerged from genuine pain—stories of rejection, bullying, and abuse. Many people have been deeply hurt by those who used “truth” as a weapon rather than a gift. So it’s understandable that a cultural reaction would follow.
But the reaction has become its own form of oppression. Today, love is measured by agreement. If you don’t affirm someone’s self-identity, you are “unsafe.” If you believe something different about sexuality, gender, or truth, you are branded harmful—even if your words are spoken with kindness, patience, and humility.
In this new moral order, disagreement is violence. And “being loving” now means being silent—unless you’re celebrating someone’s chosen path.
This isn’t compassion. It’s coercion.
Biblical Love Isn’t Blind
Scripture paints a very different picture of love. Real love tells the truth, even when the truth is hard. Real love doesn’t flatter or affirm sin. Real love confronts—not to destroy, but to rescue.
Jesus didn’t go around affirming people in their brokenness. He met them in their sin, but He never left them there. He forgave the woman caught in adultery—but He also said, “Go and sin no more.” He dined with tax collectors—but called them to leave their greed. He healed the man at Bethesda—but warned him, “Sin no more, that nothing worse may happen to you” (John 5:14).
If Jesus had only affirmed, He would have been popular. But He loved too much for that.
The Problem with Affirmation Alone
Affirmation without transformation is sentiment without substance. It may feel kind in the moment, but it leaves people where they are—often in chains.
Imagine a doctor who discovers a treatable cancer in your body, but affirms you instead: “You’re perfect just as you are.” That’s not love. That’s malpractice. Why? Because true love confronts what is deadly—even when it’s uncomfortable.
In the same way, Christians cannot affirm what God calls sin—not because we’re harsh, but because we care. The gospel doesn’t affirm everything about us. It exposes us, convicts us, and then saves us.
That’s love.
Why This Matters for the Church
Many churches today are tempted to choose one of two paths:
- The Path of Compromise: Soften the message. Redefine sin. Avoid offense. Replace truth with therapy-speak. Affirm rather than challenge.
- The Path of Combative Certainty: Shout louder. Mock the world. Treat people as ideological enemies instead of image-bearers. Defend the truth, but forget grace.
Both are errors. One fears man. The other forgets mercy.
The right path is harder—but it’s better. It’s the path of Jesus: full of grace and truth. Gentle and unyielding. Compassionate but clear.
Real Love in Practice
So how do we love people well in a culture obsessed with affirmation?
Here are five truths that help anchor us:
- Truth and Love Are Not Enemies.
You don’t have to choose between being truthful and being loving. In fact, if you’re not both, you’re neither. - Disagreement Is Not Hatred.
Disagreeing with someone’s identity or lifestyle doesn’t mean you hate them. If that were true, Jesus would be the most hateful person who ever lived. - Feelings Are Real, But Not Final.
Our emotions are powerful—but they’re not infallible. We need something steadier than our inner compass. We need God’s Word. - Affirmation Without Christ Is a Dead End.
Even if someone feels “seen” or “empowered” by affirmation, it won’t save them. Only Jesus can. - Our Identity Comes from God, Not the Mirror.
We are not self-created beings. We are made in God’s image. That means we receive our identity, not invent it.
Courage for the Moment
You will be called unloving. You may be unfriended, blocked, or mocked. People may say you’re on the wrong side of history. But the question is: are you on the side of truth?
We need courage—not the kind that argues online all day, but the kind that gently says what is true when silence would be easier. The kind that loves people enough to speak—even when it costs us. The kind that remembers: “Better is open rebuke than hidden love” (Proverbs 27:5).
Final Word
Christian love doesn’t mean affirming everything about someone. It means calling them to the One who can make them whole.
It means loving enough to say hard things with soft hearts. It means refusing to lie to someone just because the truth might hurt. And it means remembering that the most loving Person who ever lived—Jesus Christ—was hated, rejected, and crucified.
Not because He affirmed everyone.
But because He loved them enough to tell the truth.
Tom's Theology Blog 
Leave a comment