Reaching the Wounded Behind the Words
This special blog is only available to subscribers. Please keep and eye out for my upcoming book, Mere Christianity for the Digital Age: Can Faith Survive the Internet? (available this fall from Trilogy Publishing) and keep it in prayer.
“The Lord is near to the brokenhearted and saves the crushed in spirit.”
— Psalm 34:18
Not every skeptic is angry. But many angry skeptics are deeply wounded.
Behind the bold memes and biting sarcasm, there’s often a story. And behind that story, there’s often pain. The temptation is to reply to mockery with logic. But sometimes, the most Christlike response is compassion.
This isn’t a new idea. It goes back to Jesus Himself—and even further, into the world He was born into: the Jewish world of the Second Temple period.
The Hurt Behind the Hostility
During the Second Temple period, many Jews were not skeptics in the modern sense—but they were disillusioned. Rome ruled their land. Herod’s Temple glittered, but many questioned its legitimacy. Pharisees promoted strict purity, while the Sadducees aligned with power. Some withdrew into separatism (like the Essenes), and others lashed out in zealotry.
And in the midst of this fractured, skeptical, wounded religious culture, Jesus arrived—not with a sword or a scroll—but with questions, compassion, and healing.
He listened to the bleeding woman. He touched the leper. He noticed Zacchaeus. He wept with Mary. He spoke gently to the woman caught in adultery.
He looked past the surface insult and saw the brokenness underneath.
Nicodemus and the Nighttime Search
Nicodemus is a powerful example of a “skeptic” in the Second Temple world. A Pharisee, a member of the Sanhedrin, educated in the Torah—he had reasons to dismiss Jesus.
But something drew him.
So he came—quietly, at night.
And Jesus didn’t shame him for it. He engaged. He spoke of birth, Spirit, wind, and light. He didn’t mock Nicodemus’ confusion; He invited him to go deeper.
That conversation shaped Nicodemus. He would later defend Jesus publicly, and finally, help bury Him.
Sometimes, the ones who come quietly in confusion become the ones who stand boldly in the end.
The Mockers at the Cross
When Jesus hung on the cross, mockers surrounded Him. Soldiers jeered. Religious leaders sneered. One thief hurled insults.
But one didn’t.
Somewhere between the pain and the dying, one of those men—hardened by violence, probably numb to religion—softened. He saw something different in Christ’s suffering.
“Remember me,” he said.
And Jesus did.
That man is the gospel’s most dramatic latecomer—and he came not because someone debated him, but because someone forgave him in the moment of mockery.
Why This Still Matters
Today’s online landscape is filled with dismissive tones and harsh words. But the question we must ask is this:
What’s behind the tone?
- Some mock because they were wounded by a church.
- Some lash out because they never saw real faith lived out.
- Some question because they watched a parent suffer and never got answers.
- Some are sarcastic because it’s safer than being sincere.
If we can learn to listen past the mockery, we may discover what they truly long for.
A Jewish Parallel: The Psalms of Lament
Second Temple Jews were not strangers to pain. Many Psalms written and sung in that era were laments—songs of unresolved grief, protest, and hope. “Why, O Lord, do You stand far off?” “How long, O Lord?”
These weren’t signs of faithlessness. They were cries of faithful suffering.
Many atheists today don’t need a debate—they need to know it’s okay to lament. To grieve. To rage honestly and still be seen by God.
When we give them room to express pain without pouncing with answers, we reflect a God who heard Israel’s cries in Egypt, who saw Hagar in the wilderness, and who noticed Bartimaeus crying out on the roadside.
Practical Ways to Respond with Compassion
- Pause before replying
Ask: Is this person mocking ideas—or crying out from experience? - Ask questions that invite story
“Has something happened that shaped how you feel about this?” - Resist the urge to diagnose
Not every conversation needs a fix. Some just need presence. - Respond with dignity—even if they don’t
Your tone may linger longer than your argument. - Remember your own story
Were you ever angry at God? Hurt by believers? Start from there.
A Personal Word
Some of the most hostile messages I’ve received have ended with a surprising confession:
“I’m just tired.”
“I used to believe.”
“My dad was a pastor.”
“I’ve never told anyone this before…”
Sometimes, just by refusing to argue, you give someone permission to be honest.
And that’s where healing begins.
Final Thought
We don’t need to match mockery with mockery. We need to look past it.
Jesus didn’t just die for polite seekers. He died for hostile crowds, confused Pharisees, broken prostitutes, and bitter criminals. He died for the angry, the sarcastic, and the skeptical.
And He invites us to do the same—to reach behind the mask of mockery and see the image of God waiting to be remembered.
You might be the only Christian who doesn’t flinch when they rage.
Stand your ground—but soften your gaze.
They may be mocking God today—but mourning the silence tomorrow.
Be there for both.
Leave a Reply